Crossing the T

Life at the intersection of Church and Trans with Rev. Allyson Robinson

The feminine mistake?

My good friend Joyce, who is navigating a gender transition, writes about her annoyance at having the word “effeminate” applied to her by those who do not yet know she is transgendered:

I guess I had thought of myself as feminine (or at least androgynous) because of my obvious shift in sex and gender, and for some reason the word effeminate grated on me. Although it shouldn’t bother me, it did, and I’m wondering why. Maybe it was my old self sitting up, taking notice, and arguing with whatever macho pride he could muster. That’s plausible and is almost certainly a component of my annoyance, but I think there’s something else going on, if you’ll permit me to explain.

What follows is a wonderful double deconstruction of our culture’s gender norms and Joyce’s own emotional response to them.  To make her point, she asks us to consider the significance of two statements:

  • “You have become quite feminine lately.”
  • “You have become quite effeminate lately.”
  • While Joyce plays on the dichotomy between what is “natural” and “unnatural” inherent in these observations, a different distinction came to my mind.  The first statement is value-neutral.  In and of itself it does not assign any moral value, positive or negative, to being or becoming feminine.  The second, however, clearly assigns a negative moral value to femininity.  It implies that taking on feminine traits is ethically questionable, culturally undesirable, or personally unsuitable. 

    The first statement affirms the value of femininity and of women.  The second is patently misogynistic. 

    I’m with Joyce–when I was still presenting myself to the world as a man, I would have been mortified to be thought of as effeminate.  I think, though, that the offense in that kind of statement is not really against the person to whom it is directed.  It is against women and womanhood.



      Hazumu Osaragi wrote @

    Julia Serano’s book ‘Whipping Girl’ makes the same point about the neutral/negative connotations.

      Allyson wrote @

    Thanks so much for the comment, Hazumu–and I love your pen name! I haven’t read Serano’s book yet, but from what I’ve heard, I think it will prove very influential in the ongoing debate over the trans experience.

    Leave a Reply

    Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

    You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

    Google+ photo

    You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


    Connecting to %s

    %d bloggers like this: